There was an accident a few weeks ago at the Red River Gorge where a climber fell going to the second bolt and the rope was cut completely through by the fixed draw's sharp-edged, rope-end biner at the first bolt.

If you recall the previous testing and commentary on this subject, I had stated that I'd only seen ropes getting "sheathed" by sharp-edged biners—usually mid-route—and subsequently learned of an accident in the Czech Republic (in a climbing gym) where the rope-grooved sharp biner (also at the first bolt) severed the rope completely, resulting in the climber hitting the ground.  Luckily in both cases, the climbers were not badly injured.

Which biners get badly grooved and why?

From my experience falling all over routes, all over the county, I've noticed three primary locations where fixed biners become badly grooved:

1)    First Bolt
Belayers typically stand too far away from the wall.  This results in a sharp angle in the rope from the belayer to the first biner and then up the route.  When lowering a climber, the rope, often dirty and gritty, slowly wears a groove in the biner.  Both incidents I've heard of where the rope was cut completely, it was the first bolt that was the culprit.
2)    Crux Bolt
Many climbers being lowered off the same biner (falling at the crux onto the same bolt).  This has the same effect as above.  The sharp angle of the rope wrapping around the biner and the weight of the climber being lowered is what is allowing the rope to slowly cut through the biner.
3)    Out of line bolts
Often if the bolt line isn't straight, an out-of-line biner can end up being grooved.  Once again, this is caused by the rope and its angle running over the biner surface.

SETUP

  • Sharp-edged biner (actual biner used in test shown directly above)
  • 80 kg mass
  • brand new 10.2 mm rope
  • One harsh, but realistic, drop
  • Static belay

RESULTS

  • Rope cut on the FIRST drop (see image below)
  • Max load reached - ~7 kN

MORE STORIES

Yma O Hyd

YMA O HYD

Watch BD Athlete Hazel Findlay attempt her hardest trad route since becoming a mother. 

READ ARTICLE
Hazel Findlay’s Fall Picks

HAZEL FINDLAY’S FALL PICKS

Fall favorites from one of the world’s best trad climbers after becoming a mom.

READ ARTICLE
BD.dry™

BD.DRY™

Waterproof. Breathability. Durability. Stretch. Our 2.5L and 3L BD.dry waterproof technology is designed to keep...

READ ARTICLE
How to Choose a Ski Pack

HOW TO CHOOSE A SKI PACK

A guide to Black Diamond’s touring backpacks.

READ ARTICLE
A Swell Weekend in the Desert

A SWELL WEEKEND IN THE DESERT

Beat the Moab crowds and head northwest for climbing, running, and bouldering in the San...

READ ARTICLE
Designed For The Deep

DESIGNED FOR THE DEEP

The Black Diamond 2026 Winter Catalog

READ ARTICLE
The New Normal

THE NEW NORMAL

Black Diamond Athlete Hazel Findlay sets off on her first climbing trip as a mum,...

READ ARTICLE
Indian Creek Rack

INDIAN CREEK RACK

The essentials for sending splitters in the desert.

READ ARTICLE
Black Diamond Presents: Hard Sends with Seb Bouin—Le Chant des Muses (5.15b)

BLACK DIAMOND PRESENTS: HARD SENDS WITH SEB BOUIN—LE CHANT DES MUSES (5.15B)

Watch BD Athlete Seb Bouin find inspiration in an undone project near his home in...

READ ARTICLE
Making Of The Mission Duffel

MAKING OF THE MISSION DUFFEL

True Alpine-style. 

READ ARTICLE
Anything But Mid: How to Navigate the World of Midlayers

ANYTHING BUT MID: HOW TO NAVIGATE THE WORLD OF MIDLAYERS

Our essential layering picks for cold-weather mountain pursuits.

READ ARTICLE
Gear Myths: Does Anyone Use Stoppers Anymore?

GEAR MYTHS: DOES ANYONE USE STOPPERS ANYMORE?

They started the clean climbing revolution; now they may be a relic of the past.

READ ARTICLE
The Founder

THE FOUNDER

A film about the life of Peter Metcalf and the creation of BD.

READ ARTICLE
Black Diamond’s Love Letters to Indian Creek

BLACK DIAMOND’S LOVE LETTERS TO INDIAN CREEK

Bears Ears National Monument has been reduced (again). We are angry, but our love for...

READ ARTICLE
The Black Diamond Fleece Guide

THE BLACK DIAMOND FLEECE GUIDE

Fleece that provides foundational warmth for any pursuit.

READ ARTICLE